McMillan Shakespeare (MMS)
14-07-26
McMillan Shakespeare Limited (MMS) is a Company that is engaged in
1.salary packaging,
2.novated car leasing (helped by EV sales),
3.disability plan management (NDIS) .,
plus support co-ordination, fleet asset management and related financial products and disability support plan coordination for government, corporate, and charity workers services.
A bit expensive at the moment .. aug 2026.
Buy around $15 ??
Lots of debt (700% debt to equity)
Is the company SIQ (Smart group a better buy?)
Core Services Provided
- Salary Packaging: Helps workers pay for certain items from their pre-tax pay.
- Novated Leasing: Sets up tax-effective car financing and running cost plans through work.
- Fleet Management: Manages and finances vehicle fleets for businesses.
- Disability Services: Helps people manage their funding and support plans.
--------------------
ASX:MMS (McMillan Shakespeare) has staged a strong recovery over the past five years, driven by resilient salary packaging and novated leasing demand. Profits steadily climbed from COVID-era lows, with the company commanding a massive Return on Equity (ROE) well above 50% and maintaining robust dividends, despite carrying high levels of corporate debt. [1, 2, 3, 4]
Financial Highlights over the Last 5 Years
- Profit (NPAT): After dropping to A$32.3M during the pandemic (FY21), annual net profit rebounded sharply. The company posted A$83.5M in FY24 and A$95.3M in FY25, carrying this momentum into FY26 where it reported a 9% year-on-year increase in 1H FY26 net income. [, 2]
- Debt: The company holds A$781.1M in total debt against roughly A$112.7M in shareholder equity, resulting in an exceptionally high debt-to-equity ratio. However, much of this is structural fleet funding debt. It's leases on cars that they package up and sell to a bank. The core corporate Debt/EBITDA ratio remains at a comfortable 0.5x, and the interest coverage ratio is a healthy 4.2x. [1, 3]
- Return on Equity (ROE): MMS is a highly capital-efficient business. Driven by its lean asset base and consistent profit generation, the ROE has averaged between 45% and 88% over the period. [, 2, 3, 4]
- Dividends: The company has rewarded shareholders consistently, distributing a 100% payout ratio of normalized earnings with yields frequently hovering around 7% to 8% fully franked. [1, 2]
.....................
These guys are heavily involved in the NDIS ... will they be effected by the future cost cutting going on with the government?
.........................
ROIC vs WACC 2026
McMillan Shakespeare Limited (ASX:MMS) maintains a strong positive economic spread, with its return on invested capital (ROIC) consistently exceeding its weighted average cost of capital (WACC) over the past 10 years. [1, 2]
- Current Metrics: MMS displays a trailing ROIC of roughly 15.98% to 22.42% (depending on exact capital definitions like ROCE) against a WACC of approximately 6.47%, indicating robust and ongoing shareholder value creation. [1, 2]
Capital Efficiency and Value Creation
..........
The 10-year historical Price-to-Earnings (P/E) ratio for McMillan Shakespeare Limited (ASX: MMS) reflects steady, low-double-digit trading multiples, punctuated by a massive anomaly in 2020 driven by pandemic-induced earnings compression. [1, 2, 3]
As of late 2026, MMS trades at a trailing twelve months (TTM) P/E ratio of approximately 11.9x to 12.7x. [1, 2, 3]
10-Year Historical P/E Ratio Data (Year-End)
The table below presents the year-end P/E ratios for ASX:MMS over the last decade: [1]
| Year | P/E Ratio | Key Driver / Context |
|---|---|---|
| 2026 (TTM) | 11.9x – 12.7x | High novated leasing demand driven by EV incentives. |
| 2025 | 11.3x | Strong earnings recovery offset by a heavily leveraged balance sheet. |
| 2024 | 19.5x | Normalization of operations following regulatory stability. |
| 2023 | 50.7x | Elevated due to transient post-pandemic margin contractions. |
| 2022 | 11.7x | Subdued multiple amidst global interest rate tightening cycles. |
| 2021 | 15.6x | Early rebound phase in corporate salary packaging and fleet management. |
| 2020 | 562.0x | Pandemic Outlier: Earnings collapsed during lockdowns, creating a math anomaly. |
| 2019 | 15.2x | Typical pre-pandemic operational run-rate. |
| 2018 | 22.5x | Peak cyclical valuation driven by organic growth momentum. |
| 2017 | 13.2x | Stable mid-market valuation. |
| 2016 | 10.4x | Value territory baseline. |
Key Takeaways for Valuation Analysis
- The 2020 Distortion: The 10-year statistical average is heavily skewed upward to 72.8x by the 562x spike in 2020. Excluding this massive outlier, the true median historical P/E ratio is 16.2x. [1, 2]
- Current Discount vs. History: At its current ~12x P/E range, MMS is trading below its historic median multiple. While this signals an inexpensive entry point, market analysts highlight that the compressed multiple reflects heightened risks, specifically negative free cash flows and increased leverage to fund its auto-ecosystem expansion. [1, 2, 3, 4]
...............
MMS vs SIQ
McMillan Shakespeare Limited (ASX: MMS) trades at a lower valuation multiple than its direct peer Smartgroup Corporation (ASX: SIQ), reflecting a historical discount despite comparable exposure to the Australian salary packaging and novated leasing oligopoly. [1, 2, 3]
📊 Valuation Multiple Comparison
💡 Why MMS Trades at a Discount
- Operating Margins: SIQ achieves higher operational efficiency with operating margins near 35%, compared to MMS around 25%–34%. [1, 2]
✅ Investment Takeaway
- Value Play: MMS offers a cheaper entry point and a higher dividend yield. [1]
- Growth Play: SIQ commands its multiple via superior margin conversion and consistent execution.
.....
Buffett analysis
McMillan Shakespeare (ASX:MMS) demonstrates exceptional financial efficiency with an ultra-high historical Return on Equity (ROE) that comfortably exceeds Warren Buffett’s structural benchmarks. However, an analysis of its underlying capital allocation reveals that this performance is heavily influenced by financial leverage rather than purely organic equity compounding. [1, 2, 3, 4]
Historical ROE Trends
Over the long term, McMillan Shakespeare's average 10-year ROE sits at 29.01%. In recent years, this metric has experienced an explosive upward trend: [1]
| Year | Return on Equity (ROE) | Net Profit After Tax (NPAT) | Shareholders' Equity |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 | 69.9% | $83.5M | $128.8M |
| 2025 | 85.7% | $95.3M | $112.8M |
| 2026 | 84.9% | $106.1M | $126.4M |
Comparison to Warren Buffett Benchmarks
1. The ROE Hurdle
- Buffett Benchmark: Consistent ROE above 15% without relying on excessive financial engineering. [1]
- MMS Assessment: Passes comfortably. Even at its lowest point over the last decade (a brief dip to -14.28% during the 2020 pandemic lockdowns), its normalized operating state produces premium returns well above the baseline. [1]
2. Capital Allocation & Retention
- Buffett Benchmark: Companies should retain earnings only if each dollar retained generates at least one dollar of market value. Otherwise, they must return capital via dividends or share buybacks. [1]
- MMS Assessment: Hybrid Framework. MMS behaves like a mature cash cow. It retains minimal capital to grow organically.
- Payout Ratio: The company features a high payout ratio (86% in 2026, down from a capital-returning 120% in 2024).
- High Yield: This capital discipline rewards shareholders with a trailing dividend yield of ~6.8% to 6.9%.
- Because they distribute almost all earnings, the denominator (Shareholders' Equity) stays artificially low, which mathematically inflates the ROE. [1, 2, 3]
3. Debt Decisions & Leverage
- Buffett Benchmark: Buffett strongly prefers companies that generate high returns using little to no debt (ideally keeping Debt-to-Equity under 70%). [1, 2]
- MMS Assessment: Structural Fail. On paper, MMS has a total Debt-to-Equity ratio exceeding 720% ($771.8M in long-term debt against $126.4M in equity).
- The Nuance: As a fleet management and asset finance provider, a substantial portion of this debt is "non-recourse" or warehouse facility debt used directly to fund the underlying vehicle leases.
- To filter out this distortion, Buffett looks at Return on Capital Employed (ROCE) to analyze the business independent of its capital structure. MMS's ROCE is a robust 15% to 22%, confirming that the operational engine remains highly efficient compared to its peers. [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]
Investment Summary
From a classic Buffett perspective, McMillan Shakespeare represents a high-moat, highly profitable market leader in the salary packaging space. However, its massive leverage profile means it does not fit the profile of a pristine, debt-free compounder. Instead, it operates efficiently as a leveraged financial services vehicle that converts capital into high dividend distributions.
......................
No comments:
Post a Comment